Horizontal Property
Translation generated by AI. Access the original version
Illegality of works affecting common areas due to lack of consent from the community
The Supreme Court (TS) has confirmed that the owners of a premises could not completely cover the building's courtyard or install certain smoke and ventilation ducts without the consent of the community.
In the building there were two owners . The holders of a premises and another dwelling, who accounted for 65% of participation in the community, decided to convert the premises into a restaurant -pizzeria. To adapt it, they demolished an old bathroom located in the inner courtyard, they covered the entire courtyard and installed a smoke chimney and a ventilation duct to the roof. One of these passed through the terrace of the other owner.
The owner of the upper dwelling went to court to request that the altered situation be restored , because she had not given her consent. At first, she lost the case, although it was considered that the patio was common , but for private use, it was understood that the works improved health standards and that no damages had been proven.
Later, the Court partially upheld her claim. It declared illegal the covering and the two conduits, and ordered to restore the patio according to the expert report. The owners of the premises appealed to the TS, but it has rejected their appeal. the courtyard according to the expert report. The owners of the premises appealed to the TS, but it has rejected their appeal.
The Court explains that being able to use the patio exclusively does not mean being its owner nor does it authorize to close it or to intervene in it and in the terrace of another owner. It also does not consider that adapt the premises for a restaurant is a necessary work of conservation, safety, habitability or accessibility. Furthermore, it indicates that the greater flexibility to carry out works in premises does not eliminate, in this case, the need for unanimity.
Finally, the TS rejects that the neighbor abused their right to claim. They had a legitimate interest in protecting the courtyard, their terrace, and their rights.
In situations of controversy related to the execution of works that affect or may affect common elements, our professionals can advise you in defending your interestsCONTENIDO RELACIONADO
-
Urban leases
Eviction action for precarious possession by the owner to recover possession of a property
-
Payment of community fees
Illegality of the daily surcharge for late payment of community fees
-
Changes in the rental housing reduction
How have the reductions in personal income tax been after the validation of the new housing decree?
This website uses both its own and third-party cookies to analyze our services and navigation on our website in order to improve its contents (analytical purposes: measure visits and sources of web traffic). The legal basis is the consent of the user, except in the case of basic cookies, which are essential to navigate this website.